well i really dont have an issue with how its enforced but if any type of discussion about a malicious program is against the rules, the scope of rule 5 should go further than "asking for help". If a new person joins the server and reads rule 5 they would have no idea talking about their keylogger for their cybersecurity class homework is against the rules. Or on the other hand, discussion of "malicious" / red-team programs *should* be allowed unless it is evident it is going to be used in a way that breaks laws or TOS
This is not a new conversation.